Film Review: Where Have You Been? (ŠTO TE NEMA) (2024) - Bosnia and Herzegovina / Italy / USA / UK
Reviewed by Andrew Chan (Film Critic Circle of Australia)
I rated it 7.5/10
Rating: ★ ★ ★ 1/2
Support my reviews by buying me a Coffee! https://buymeacoffee.com/neofilmblog
Support our reviews by buying from official DVDs / Blu Rays at NeoFilmShop.com
There is a moment in Mirko Pincelli’s “Where Have You Been” that captures everything the film is trying to say. The camera lingers on a single ceramic coffee cup, one of thousands laid out in neat, endless rows. It’s empty, but steam rises from it, curling into the cool Bosnian air as if the phantom who should be drinking it just stepped away for a moment. That wisp of steam is the ghost in the room. It is the film’s thesis: a visual representation of an absence so profound it still has weight.
This is not a documentary about the Srebrenica Genocide. Not really. You won't find harrowing archival footage of Ratko Mladić walking through the deserted streets of the UN "safe area," nor will you hear the sound of gunfire. Pincelli understands that some horrors are too vast to be contained by re-enactment. Instead, he trains his lens on the aftermath, on the "quiet work" of remembering. His subject is Aida Šehović, the artist behind ŠTO TE NEMA ("Where Have You Been?"), a nomadic monument that has traveled the world for 15 years, collecting a ceramic coffee cup for each of the 8,372 Bosniak men and boys killed in July 1995.
The film’s greatest strength is its almost radical restraint. Pincelli trusts the symbolism of the ritual. He films the clinking of cups, the hands of strangers setting them down, the steam rising against the impossibly green and tranquil Bosnian countryside. This contrast—between the pastoral beauty of the land and the stark geometry of the memorial—is where the film finds its haunting power. It asks us to consider how a landscape can hold a memory that the people living on it are still trying to process. The cinematography has the patience of a photographer, capturing grief not as a scream, but as a long, slow exhale.
But that patience is a double-edged sword. At times, "Where Have You Been" drifts into a meditative state that borders on the somnambulant. The "slow cinema" approach is certainly meant to mirror the process of mourning, but for a viewer coming in cold—someone who might need a reminder of why these cups matter—the film’s meandering pace can feel like a test of endurance. We see the monument in different cities, and while each location adds a cup, the visual language remains the same. It is beautiful, but repetitive.
There is a more urgent, perhaps more difficult, movie hiding in the margins of this one. We get fleeting glimpses of the friction Šehović faced: the truck drivers afraid to cross certain borders, the political pushback from those who still deny the genocide. A deeper exploration of this geopolitical tension could have provided a crucial narrative spine, a dramatic counterweight to the otherwise somber tone. After all, the act of remembering becomes heroic precisely because there are powerful forces demanding we forget.
To watch "Where Have You Been" is to understand that the past is not even past. The history is clinical—the fall of the "safe area," the 8,372 dead, the ongoing search for the thousand still missing—but the grief is not. By returning the monument to its origin in Potočari, the film forces us to confront the temporal distance. It has been thirty years. The wounds have scarred over, but as the steam rising from the cups suggests, the flesh beneath is still tender.
"Where Have You Been" is a vital, necessary piece of work, but it is not always a captivating one. It is a visual eulogy that prioritizes atmosphere over narrative momentum. It asks a profound question—what does the act of remembering actually look like a generation later?—and answers it with the patience of a stonecutter. For that, it deserves respect. But for the casual viewer, that meditative chisel may work a little too slowly. It is a deeply moving tribute to the resilience of the human spirit, provided your spirit is ready to sit in silence for a while. (Neo, 2026)